Identifying Chemistry Students’ Baseline Systems Thinking Skills When Constructing System Maps for a Topic on Climate Change (Journal Article)
Alisha R. Szozda, Peter G. Mahaffy, and Alison B. Flynn
Identifying Chemistry Students’ Baseline Systems Thinking Skills When Constructing System Maps for a Topic on Climate Change (Journal Article) - USA :American Chemical Society ,May 2023 - 1763–1776p. - American Chemical Society, Volume 100, Issue 5 .
***______________***
Abstract-
New resources have recently been emerging for educators to implement systems thinking (ST) in chemistry education, including a proposed set of ST skills. While these efforts aim to make ST implementation easier, little is known about how to assess these skills in a chemistry context. In this study, we investigated ST skills employed by students who constructed system maps of a topic related to climate change. Eighteen undergraduate chemistry students from first- to third-year participated in this study. We designed and implemented a ST intervention to capture how students engaged with three ST tasks, performed individually and collaboratively. In our analysis, we focused on 11 ST skills that aligned with five characteristics proposed in a recent study. We found that participants demonstrated most of these ST skills when engaging with the ST tasks, with nuances. Participants’ system maps: (1) lacked concepts and connections at the submicroscopic level, (2) included multiple types of connections but few circular loops and causal connections, (3) lacked causal reasoning, although participants did predict how their system maps changed over time, (4) demonstrated the breadth of connections but did not describe human connections to the underlying chemistry of climate change topics. These findings identify aspects of ST where chemistry educators need to place emphasis when teaching ST skills to chemistry students and when guiding learning activities and other assessments. Using our findings, we created an adaptable ST rubric for the chemistry community as a tool for assessing ST skills.
0021-9584
RIEBPL Library
Assessment
Upper-Division Undergraduate
Second-Year Undergraduate
First-Year Undergraduate
Qualitative Analysis
Systems Thinking
540.7
Identifying Chemistry Students’ Baseline Systems Thinking Skills When Constructing System Maps for a Topic on Climate Change (Journal Article) - USA :American Chemical Society ,May 2023 - 1763–1776p. - American Chemical Society, Volume 100, Issue 5 .
***______________***
Abstract-
New resources have recently been emerging for educators to implement systems thinking (ST) in chemistry education, including a proposed set of ST skills. While these efforts aim to make ST implementation easier, little is known about how to assess these skills in a chemistry context. In this study, we investigated ST skills employed by students who constructed system maps of a topic related to climate change. Eighteen undergraduate chemistry students from first- to third-year participated in this study. We designed and implemented a ST intervention to capture how students engaged with three ST tasks, performed individually and collaboratively. In our analysis, we focused on 11 ST skills that aligned with five characteristics proposed in a recent study. We found that participants demonstrated most of these ST skills when engaging with the ST tasks, with nuances. Participants’ system maps: (1) lacked concepts and connections at the submicroscopic level, (2) included multiple types of connections but few circular loops and causal connections, (3) lacked causal reasoning, although participants did predict how their system maps changed over time, (4) demonstrated the breadth of connections but did not describe human connections to the underlying chemistry of climate change topics. These findings identify aspects of ST where chemistry educators need to place emphasis when teaching ST skills to chemistry students and when guiding learning activities and other assessments. Using our findings, we created an adaptable ST rubric for the chemistry community as a tool for assessing ST skills.
0021-9584
RIEBPL Library
Assessment
Upper-Division Undergraduate
Second-Year Undergraduate
First-Year Undergraduate
Qualitative Analysis
Systems Thinking
540.7